Read more about Pauly and Aubrey's relationship here, and share your thoughts on this romantic connection in the comments!
In “The Little Hours,” Aubrey Plaza plays a foul-mouthed nun in 14th century Italy, the kind of sarcastic humor Plaza does best.
The breakup comes at a strange time for the former “Jersey Shore” star, who is going to be part of the recently-announced reunion series coming to E!
After getting together on the set of the reality series in November 2015, they announced they were done in May 2016, only to get back together soon after.
"You'll see on the show we had a really really strong connection right from the jump," he revealed.
"It was an automatic connection, just a bond, a friendship and we could just relate to each other and stuff like that.
When the MTV series following his GTL days on the boardwalk and late night Karma fights with on-again-off-again girlfriend Sammi "Sweetheart" Giancola ended in 2012, co-stars Nicole "Snooki" Polizzi, Jenni "Jwoww" Farley, Pauly D and Deena Nicole Cortese all appeared on other reality fare.'s "Famously Single" though, a move he made after some "recon" from Pauly D, who appeared on the E! He left with Aubrey [O'Day] and they're still together so it was kind of motivation to do it because I hadn't done anything since 'Jersey Shore' because I was always like, kinda like traumatized in a way.I definitely did my recon, watched the show, texted him." During filming, he actually started falling for co-star and Kardashian BFF Malika Haqq, though the two have since split.It was a long time coming — they were always on and off.But it seems like it’s done for good now.” Last month, they were still together. News that she was “the one,” adding, "I’ve learned so much being in it — I’ve learned don’t assume anything.